13 Years to the Disengagement – Much has Changed

13 years since the disengagement and Israel is a very different society today, the sobering realities having clarified the true nature of the “peace” our neighbors seek.

Demolition of Ganey Tal in Gush Katif, during the disengagement. 22/8/2005 (Photo - Yossi Zamir/Flash90)

This week marks thirteen years since the uprooting of the Gush Katif settlements during the infamous Israeli unilateral disengagement from Gaza. The event that signified a period of the great crisis in Israeli society. For 13 years we have been trying to heal the rift between the various sectors in our society, trying to understand what happened then.

I had just been discharged from my military service back in those days, having served three years as a combat soldier with the Israeli Border Police Unit. I had served in the toughest sectors and during the most difficult period, the period of the Arab violence of the second Intifada. I had an older brother who served as an officer in the Gaza vicinity then and like me, it was clear to us, like all other soldiers, that we were enlisting in the IDF in order to give everything we could for our country.

The entire media those days was mobilized in favor of one purpose – advancing the disengagement plan. The demonstrations at highway intersections, the heartbreaking stories of the families that were to be uprooted, the lamentations, the prayers, the songs and the huge demonstrations in Rabin Square – none of these made a difference or left the slightest impression on them. The media was full of purpose.

Today though, in hindsight, we are smart enough to say that the ominous predictions made at that time have come about. We indeed suffered rocket attacks, with missiles having already reached as far as Tel Aviv. It is not just missiles, there are also terror tunnels, rockets, attempts to infiltrate into towns, and now even fire-kites that are burning forests to the ground. Hamas’ desire to destroy the Jewish state has never subsided. Their aspirations have not changed, but we have.

We in Israel have sobered up and have acquired a keener understanding of the harsh realities. We still desire peace but now look at reality with open eyes. What we understand today is that our neighbors do not completely share the same aspirations and desire for this life that we do. We understand that Hamas hates us more than it loves the citizens of the Gaza Strip; it aspires for our destruction, not for prosperity and success for the Gaza Strip.

The media itself has changed as well. It is no longer that cut from the same cloth, left-wing-Tel Aviv-IDF Radio milieu, who fill the ranks of all the editorial boards and news outlets. There now exist other media options, Zionist and Israeli, that offer a variety of opinions, hailing from the periphery and from the center of the political spectrum.

The importance of settlement in Judea and Samaria is no longer presented in the media only by religious people with skullcaps and headscarves. There is also a right-wing secular representation, even from Tel Aviv itself, for which there are Israelis who say out loud, “the settlement of the Land of Israel is important to us all!”

In the past, it was convenient for the media to portray the right-wing public as a religious settler population, all of whom live beyond the mountains of darkness and send their children to spray graffiti on Arab homes. The times have changed. There is a religious right and a secular right, a traditional public, Ashkenazi, Mizrahi, who hail from the center as well as from the periphery, and there is room for everyone. Journalists are no longer above criticism with the emergence of Facebook and Twitter, and the public no longer accepts any commentary on the news as a “Torah from Sinai”, absolute authoritative.

There is much yet to be said about those days of the disengagement from Gaza and the uprooting of the Gush Katif settlements and the devastating consequences of the event on Israeli society and on Israel’s security. Perhaps the most important question we need to ask ourselves though, is whether such a move could take place in Israel today?

How would the media cover such an event today? How would the public respond to such a possibility today and how far will the citizens of Israel be willing to go in order to prevent the evacuation of Jewish settlements and the uprooting of families from their land?

(This article first appeared in Hebrew in the Israeli “Nashim” magazine and was translated with their permission)


Lital Shemesh is an Israeli Journalist and Commentator

[Find this article interesting? You can find more in depth articles on Israel and the Middle East @en.mida.org.il]

Related articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

2 comments on the article

  1. It is indeed time to face reality and understand who is the enemy, and that it wants to see us all dead. They hate us and wants us gone from planet Earth. I wish that the Left in Israel were to realize it long time ago. However, it’s better later than never.

  2. On this 13th anniversary of the injustice in Gush Katif one major casualty must be remembered, the then Prime Minister Ariel Sharon z´l was publicly condemned by the far religious right and their curse on his life prompted his long illness which made also the life of his family very sad indeed.

    It is time to force the Arab nations to take their brethren away from a place they think they own, to let the world know that the few Arab dissidents who stole an ethnic identification by calling themselves Philistines or Palestinians are a complete fake; that they belong in Jordan the second country forced into the former land of the Ottoman Empire called Palestine by Roman Emperor Hadrian in the year 135 CE

    The UN should investigate the reality of those Arab children´s education founded in outright hate to Israel and the Jewish people, only educating them for terror and disrespect for human life.

    Just as the free nations stood by in silence during the German genocide, today they stand by in silence to the impunity of all terrorist groups financed by Iran and other the oil rich Arab nations.